Image courtesy of Dalhousie University
Image courtesy of Dalhousie University

O’Neill takes the heat

December 7, 2010 /

Samantha Durnford, News Editor

Tim O’Neill finally faced the fire. In a discussion with students last week, O’Neill explained the recommendations in his report about post-secondary education in the province.

Students asked him questions, made statements, argued with him, walked out, and one even demanded an apology.

“I do think you owe students an apology for saying they wouldn’t be interested in policy,” said David Etherington, the Board of Governors representative for the King’s Students’ Union. “For suggesting we don’t have alternatives for the way post-secondary education is run,” he said. “I can assure you sir, that my constituents have many opinions. Please, come speak to students, come talk to us. We’ll give you our two cents.”

In a one on one interview after the event, O’Neill says he expected to be confronted.

“I wasn’t remotely surprised with what happened tonight. If I were in the students position, as I once was, I would probably be passionately advocating for lowering tuition fees. I understand that,” said O’Neill.

However, he is not sympathetic to students’ views.

“My job, my mandate, was not to sympathize with students or empathize with taxpayers,” he said. “It was to say: what does the evidence suggest should be done with tuition fees’ policy, and what would be the consequences if you change the policy.”

The two and a half hour discussion was more of a chance for students to say what’s on their mind to O’Neill, however, no changes will be made to his report.

One student asked, “Is this a way for you to hear students and revise your report or is this just a show so we feel we’ve had our say?”

“You’ve had ample opportunity to have your views known,” O’Neill replied. “I’ve looked at the evidence and looked at reports and had ample opportunity to see your viewpoints but you and I and the students here differ on the conclusions I’ve came to but there is no logic suggesting I need to change my report.”

Students in the crowd were visibly upset when O’Neill made a statement that students were more interested in tuition fees than the restructuring of universities.

“I didn’t think I was being arrogant in suggesting that students would be most interested in the tuition fee issue, but I certainly didn’t mean to insult anybody by suggesting that students wouldn’t have a wider range of interest than just tuition fees,” said O’Neill.

Overall, O’Neill left the McCain auditorium in one piece.

“I can’t say it was the most fun of my life,” he said. “But, it was far from being the most difficult.”

Posted in , ,

Dalhousie Gazette Staff

Read more from the gazette

Local university series fostered Jewish and Indigenous conversation and connections

Series explored shared histories, cultural preservation and revitalization

Dal Student Life hosts not-so-haunted campus tour

Campus tour looks inside Dalhousie’s haunted history

Budgeting tips, from the provincial government

How did years of spending and surplus turn into the province’s deepest-ever cuts?

Hungover, Hungry and on a Budget

Where the coffee flows and the prices stay low

How has affording to be a Dalhousie student changed in the last 30 years?

Alumni and a current student show how life as a student has changed

Affordability means nothing in Halifax

What does it mean to afford living in a city with rising rent, tuition, grocery and gas prices?

Connect with the Gazette