I find it ridiculous for anyone to demand that students—in the midst of protesting the impoverishing system that deems university education a commodity—donate money in order for their protest to be legitimated.
I find it ridiculous for anyone to demand that students—in the midst of protesting the impoverishing system that deems university education a commodity—donate money in order for their protest to be legitimated.

All Out: the photo that defined a moment in the students’ protest

When confronted with inequality during the protest, students' actions didn't match up with their words

November 2, 2016 /

There were a lot of positive aspects of today’s student protest to end tuition fees for university, but to me, the photo above says a thousand words.

The students’ chant at the time was something along the lines of, “Drop our fees, we’re sick of mac n’ cheese,” as the group passed a young man shivering in a fleece sweater, empty Tim’s cup in hand, asking for spare change for food.

The contrast of students complaining about eating KD, and the young man begging for something to eat, turned my stomach.

I thought I would catch a moment of a student offering change, maybe even just a hug, but I saw nothing. I watched nearly 500 students who were marching for social equality turn a blind eye to a young person right in front of them, who is one of the most vulnerable victims of our society’s economic inequality.

It made it difficult to cover the rest of the march because the cheers for equality all seemed very hollow.

There were good practices of including members from the Mi’kmaq community, of recognizing we are on their land, of advocating an end to racism on campuses, but everything just seemed like a play after that.

It was as if organizers knew that cameras were on them, and they were playing to a role and checking all the boxes. When the core of their base had the opportunity to do something small to challenge the inequality they marched against, they shied away.

It’s a shame that when we allow one group to become our loudest members of society that it ultimately causes the most vulnerable, who don’t have a platform or agenda, to become silenced in conversations that should include them.

It’s true: “education is not just for the rich and white,” but students are not the only members in Halifax who are “tired, hungry and poor.” With all of the talk of camaraderie at today’s march, students should recognize that there are many others facing the same issues they are, but with far fewer resources.

Erin Brown

Read more from the gazette

$400K settlement reached in lawsuit alleging Dal profs conducted medical study on First Nation members without consent

Suit alleges two profs MRIed around 60 Mi’kmaw people without consent

The Dal review: Clayface and Pulse film reviews

Two horror movies to check out

Finance minister touts new federal budget in Halifax

Champagne spoke to business leaders about affordability, sovereignty measures in budget

Hundreds protest against Cape Breton AI data centre in Halifax

Protests held in Halifax, Port Hawkesbury and more

Local university series fostered Jewish and Indigenous conversation and connections

Series explored shared histories, cultural preservation and revitalization

Dal Student Life hosts not-so-haunted campus tour

Campus tour looks inside Dalhousie’s haunted history

Connect with the Gazette