Image courtesy of Dalhousie University
Image courtesy of Dalhousie University

$400K settlement reached in lawsuit alleging Dal profs conducted medical study on First Nation members without consent

November 18, 2026 /

A $400,000 settlement has been reached in a lawsuit alleging that two doctors who worked at Dalhousie University conducted MRI scans on Pictou Landing First Nation members without their knowledge or consent.

The lawsuit claims the doctors, employed by Dal and the QEII Health Sciences Centre, conducted MRI scans of around 60 people from the First Nation in 2017. 

Both defendants deny the allegations, which have not been tested in court. A lawyer representing the defendants declined to comment on the settlement to the Dalhousie Gazette in an email on Nov. 18.

A Nova Scotia Supreme Court judge approved the settlement on Friday, according to the plaintiff’s lawyer. The damages will be split among the members of the class action lawsuit.

The lawsuit alleges First Nation members signed up for another study at QEII, but were subjected to extra MRI scans for a “secret” separate study they did not know about. 

The two doctors, Robert Miller and Sharon Clarke, were both members of Dal’s radiology department at the time. Dr. Miller has since left Dal, where he was the head of the cardiac radiology division. Dr. Clarke is still at Dal and is currently the head of abdominal imaging.

The second study was of Indigenous people’s livers, which the First Nation members did not find out about until over a year later — during which time information from the MRIs was presented at a conference.

The lawsuit alleged both were liable for unlawful imprisonment, assault and battery, negligence and invasion of privacy, and that their actions caused “distress, humiliation, or anguish.”

The lawsuit also alleges Dr. Miller and Dr. Clarke failed to properly tell participants about serious health issues discovered in the MRI scans.

McKiggan Hebert Lawyers, who represented the First Nation members, released a statement confirming the settlement on Nov. 16.

“The lawsuit brought national and international attention to the need for full disclosure and consent when conducting health research involving Indigenous participants, and the dangers for researchers who don’t bother learning the proper way of obtaining that consent,” wrote Brian Hebert, a partner at McKiggan Hebert. “

“The lawsuit also sends the message — don’t mess with Pictou Landing First Nation.”

The lawsuit was first filed in 2020. Dal was originally named as a defendant, but was removed in 2021. The Montreal Heart Institute — which conducted the original, non-secret study — and Nova Scotia Health Authority were also removed as defendants at the same time.

Dalhousie Communications did not respond to a request for comment from the Gazette before publication.

Andrea Paul, who was the chief of Pictou Landing First Nation at the time, is named as among those subjected to the MRIs in court filings.

“As [Paul] lay inside the claustrophobic MRI chamber holding her breath and cringing from the banging sounds around her, the MRI scans generated data that revealed intimate medical information about her body without her knowledge or consent,” read a statement of claim from 2021. “She had been singled out for one reason — she was Mi’kmaq.”

The statement also said Paul, now Assembly of First Nations regional chief for Nova Scotia, “felt violated and humiliated,” when she found out about the unconscious MRI scans.

“Chief Andrea felt powerless, vulnerable and discriminated against because she was Mi’kmaq. She suffered a loss of dignity and self-esteem as a result. The other Class [action lawsuit] Members suffered the same losses and damages.”

The lawsuit also alleges that the type of behaviour exhibited by Dr. Clarke and Dr. Miller was motivated by racism, and that they were acting to advance their own careers, not the well-being of those subjected to MRIs or Indigenous people generally.

Dal described Miller as having been an “integral member” of the radiology department in 2018, after he left the university. According to Dal’s website, he was previously president of Doctors Nova Scotia. Dr. Clarke still works with QEII.

Posted in
Avatar photo

Dylan Follett

Dylan is a second-year political science and journalism student. Last year he was the Gazette's Assistant Opinions Editor, and frequently contributed to the Gazette's news section, including coverage of the student strike. He's reported stories for a variety of outlets from Halifax, his hometown of Toronto, New York City, and across the Northwest Territories. Dylan spent this past summer reporting for a newspaper in Yellowknife, N.W.T., where he covered everything from politics to housing to plane crash investigations. His work was also republished nationally through the Local Journalism Initiative. Dylan is excited to get back to Halifax and work with the passionate and talented people at the Gazette. When he's not working, Dylan enjoys reading, following politics, playing sports, and arguing. You can contact Dylan via email at news@dalgazette.com

Read more from the gazette

The Dal review: Clayface and Pulse film reviews

Two horror movies to check out

Finance minister touts new federal budget in Halifax

Champagne spoke to business leaders about affordability, sovereignty measures in budget

Hundreds protest against Cape Breton AI data centre in Halifax

Protests held in Halifax, Port Hawkesbury and more

Local university series fostered Jewish and Indigenous conversation and connections

Series explored shared histories, cultural preservation and revitalization

Dal Student Life hosts not-so-haunted campus tour

Campus tour looks inside Dalhousie’s haunted history

Budgeting tips, from the provincial government

How did years of spending and surplus turn into the province’s deepest-ever cuts?

Connect with the Gazette